JAMB CBT 2025 - Candidates, Schools, Centres, Resellers - Get Ready!
JAMB CBT Software 2025 - Free Download

Three solutions contain carbonate, sulphate and sulphide ions respectively. One test that will identify just...

Chemistry
JAMB 1978

Three solutions contain carbonate, sulphate and sulphide ions respectively. One test that will identify just ONE of them completely is by addition to each of them of

  • A. barium chloride solution
  • B. dilute hydrochloric acid
  • C. lead nitrate solution
  • D. calcium chloride solution
  • E. sodium hydroxide solution
JAMB CBT 2025 - Candidates, Schools, Centres, Resellers - Get Ready!
JAMB CBT Software 2025 - Free Download
JAMB CBT Mobile App 2025 - Free Download
WAEC Past Questions, Objective & Theory, Study 100% offline, Download app now - 127076
Correct Answer: Option A
Explanation

To distinguish between carbonate, sulphate, and sulphide ions, you can use dilute hydrochloric acid (HCl) and barium chloride (BaCl\(_2\)). Carbonates will react with HCl to produce a gas that turns limewater milky, sulphates react with BaCl\(_2\) to form a white precipitate, and sulphides will produce a gas with a rotten egg smell when reacted with HCl.  

Silver nitrate solution is used to distinguish Cl-

  • When an aqueous solution of silver nitrate is added to the Cl- ion, white ppt of silver chloride is formed.

         AgNO\(_3\)(aq) + Cl\(^-\)(aq) → AgCl(s) + NO\(_3\)\(^–\)(aq)

Barium chloride solution is used to distinguish SO\(_4\)\(^{2–}\) ion.

Again,when an aqueous solution of barium chloride is added to the SO\(_4\)\(^{2–}\) ion, a white ppt of barium sulphate is formed which is not soluble in weak or strong acids.

BaCl\(_2\)(aq) + SO\(_4\)\(^{2–}\)(aq) → BaSO\(_4\)(s) + 2Cl\(^-\)(aq)

Since dilute HCl can give reaction with both Carbonate ion and Sulphide ion, then it can not be the answer because the question says "one test that will identify just one of them". 

Also, Pb(NO₃)₂ can distinguish between carbonate, sulphate, and sulphide solutions based on the formation of precipitates: PbCO₃ (white ppt), PbSO₄ (white ppt), and PbS (black) respectively.

Consequently, since BaCl\(_2\) solution will form a white precipitate only with sulphates, it implies it is the best option, and definitely our valid answer.


Report an Error Ask A Question Download App
JAMB CBT 2025 - Candidates, Schools, Centres, Resellers - Get Ready!
JAMB CBT Mobile App 2025 - Free Download
JAMB CBT Software 2025 - Free Download
WAEC Past Questions, Objective & Theory, Study 100% offline, Download app now - 127076

Contributions ({{ comment_count }})

Please wait...

{{ settings.no_comment_msg ? settings.no_comment_msg : 'There are no comments' }}

Quick Questions

Post your Contribution

Please don't post or ask to join a "Group" or "Whatsapp Group" as a comment. It will be deleted. To join or start a group, please click here

{{ quote.posted_by.display_name }}
{{ settings.form_textarea_description }}
 
JAMB CBT 2025 - Candidates, Schools, Centres, Resellers - Get Ready!
WAEC Past Questions, Objective & Theory, Study 100% offline, Download app now - 127076
JAMB CBT Software 2025 - Free Download
JAMB CBT Mobile App 2025 - Free Download
JAMB CBT Software 2025 - Free Download
JAMB CBT 2025 - Candidates, Schools, Centres, Resellers - Get Ready!
WAEC Past Questions, Objective & Theory, Study 100% offline, Download app now - 127076
JAMB CBT Mobile App 2025 - Free Download